1. Home
  2. Food & recipes

15 Best Fall Pie Recipes That Taste Delicious

If we’re being honest, we’re pie lovers through and through, especially if the pie is homemade. Even though we make pies all year round, however, autumn has always been our very favourite time to make them because we adore the seasonal flavours that come with it. That’s why we’re always on the lookout for awesome fall pie recipes we’ve never tried before.

If you’re feeling just as interested as we were in learning how to make some new kinds of scrumptious fall pie for the first time, here are 15 of the very best ideas, designs, and tutorials we’ve come across so far in our search!

1. Gluten free crustless sweet potato pie


Even though you’re a sweet lover on the hunt for good dessert recipes are you still the kind of person who has always liked the taste of savoury ingredients in your treats? Then why not stick with a classic and learn how to make it for your whole family? This gluten free, vegan crustless sweet potato pie outlined step by step on Strength and Sunshine is the perfect example of what we mean.

2. No-bake S’more pumpkin cream pie


If you’re going to make a fall pie, would you rather make it a little more unique than the usual classics that you’re used to? In that case, especially if you’re a really big sweet lover, we have a feeling you might be really into this next idea from Let’s Camp S’more! Take a better look at their tutorial to see how this no-bake S’more pumpkin cream pie was made surprisingly easily.

3. Chocolate pecan pie


Maybe you’re interested in making a delicious fall pie recipe but you’re also wondering whether you can’t put a fun twist on one of the classics? Well, if you’re even half the chocolate lover we are then we have a feeling you’ll get along very well indeed with this rich and delicious chocolate pecan pie idea outlined step by easy step on Intelligent Domestications.

4. Easy pecan cheesecake pie


Did we actually really catch your attention when we started talking about fall pie recipes involving pecans and you’re even feeling intrigued by the idea of putting a unique twist on things but you’re just not sure you like the chocolate concept specifically? In that case, we’d definitely suggest taking a look at how Simply Sweet Recipes made this pecan pie cheesecake instead!

5. Pear and honey pie


Even though you like all the classic fall flavours we’ve mentioned so far, are you actually usually more a fan of the slightly more subtle seasonal tastes that are typical this time of year? In that case, we have a feeling you’ll get along a little better with something like this gently sweet and easy pear and honey pie recipe outlined nice and clearly on Hello Creative Family.

6. Cinnamon streusel topped carrot pie


Perhaps we caught your attention quite well when we started talking about the idea of making sweet fall pies from typically savoury ingredients like vegetables but you’ve tried sweet potato pie before and you’re looking for something else? Then you just might be the perfect person to try your hand at this cinnamon streusel topped carrot pie featured on Cooking With Carlee.

7. Pumpkin slab pie


Perhaps you’ve been preparing yourself for the idea of having to make several pies this fall since your family gatherings for Thanksgiving are so large and you can’t help wondering whether there isn’t an easier way to portion things? Then we’d be willing to bet that you’ll get a real kick out of the way Sally’s Baking Addiction made this larger pumpkin slab pie instead!

8. Marshmallow brown butter pumpkin slab pie


Like us, are you totally into the idea of the combination recipes that are so popular right now, where you make something that has the best parts of more than one treat you really like? Well, if you’ve ever been a fan of marshmallows, then we think you’ll get a real kick out of the way Betty Crocker made this marshmallow brown butter pumpkin slab pie. It’s like an even sweeter version of the big-family-friendly recipe we showed you above!

9. Butternut squash pie


Perhaps you’ve always been intrigued by the idea of making sweet potato pie but, if you’re really being honest, you’ve actually always prefer squash a little more when you’re making savoury dishes? Well, your fall desserts don’t actually have to be any different! Take a better look at the recipe and tutorial featured on Serious Eats to see how they made this butternut squash pie instead.

10. Fig mascarpone tart


If you’re going to put in all the time and effort that it takes to make a delicious fall pie from scratch, would you much rather make something a little more unique and gourmet sounding, since you’re up for a challenge? Then we have a feeling you just might be the perfect person to give this awesomely decorative looking jumbo fig mascarpone tart outlined on Minty Chai a try!

11. Maple walnut pie


Were you intrigued by the idea of the pecan pies we showed you earlier on our list because you love nutty recipes but you’re in the market for a few more options? In that case, we’d definitely suggest taking a look at the way Simply Recipes made this maple walnut pie that has a bit of sweetness to balance out the other notes in a perfect way.

12. Gruyere pear pie


Perhaps you’re still thinking about the way we’ve mentioned the idea of including classically more savoury ingredients in your sweet fall pies but you’re looking for something besides the vegetable options you’ve seen? Then we’d absolutely encourage you to take a look at the way Blondie and Brownie made this gruyere pear pie that’s packed with unique flavour.

13. Pear and chocolate tart


Are we actually really catching your attention with all these scrumptious pear ideas we’ve been talking about but we just haven’t quite hit the nail on the head yet? Well, if you’re also a chocolate lover like we mentioned as well, then we’re pretty sure The Messy Baker has just the recipe for you! Take a better look at their recipe to see how this pear and chocolate tart is made.

14. Rosemary caramel apple pie


Have your very favourite seasonal fall flavours actually mostly always been the herbs rather than the fruits and vegetables? Well, we can understand that! That’s part of what makes dinner around this time of year so fragrant! We’re sure you can imagine, then, just how intrigued we were when we found this recipe from Saveur that shows you how to make rosemary caramel apple pie.

15. Fudge bottom pumpkin pie


Is classic pumpkin pie your total favourite so you’re pretty convinced that some kind of pumpkin flavour is the way you’ll end up going with your recipe, but you’re also totally willing to put a unique twist on what you love? In that case, we think you simply must check out the way The Brown Lounge made not just a pumpkin pie, but one with a bottom layer made of fudge!

Do you have another favourite fall pie recipe that you love making every year and that your family and friends go crazy for? Tell us all about it or link us to the recipe in the comments section so we can give it a try too!