You grab the giant 3-liter jug of Kirkland olive oil because it looks like the best deal on the shelf. At home, you drizzle some over a salad and taste it. Nothing much happens. No peppery bite, no grassy smell, just a mild, oily coating on the lettuce.
This is not your fault. The jug says “olive oil,” it sits right next to the extra virgin bottles, and the detail that explains the taste is printed in much smaller type. Once you know where to look, the label tells you exactly what you’re buying.
What’s actually in the jug
As Mashed reported, the front label of Costco’s 3-liter Kirkland Signature olive oil describes it as a mix of refined olive oil and 15% extra virgin olive oil. The back label lists 10 countries of origin: Argentina, Chile, Spain, Greece, Italy, Morocco, Portugal, Tunisia, Turkey and the United States. Mashed puts the price at about $22.49, or $7.50 per liter, and closer to $25 in some regions.
Here’s why it tastes so mild. Under USDA grade standards, refined olive oil is made from virgin olive oils by refining methods, and it is flavorless and odorless. The grade simply called “olive oil” is a blend of refined olive oil and virgin olive oils. By my math, 15% of a 3-liter jug is 0.45 liters of extra virgin oil, and the other 2.55 liters is the flavorless refined part.
How to read the label, step by step
- Find the grade. Look for the words “extra virgin.” If the front just says “olive oil” or mentions refined oil, it’s a blend.
- Look for a percentage. On this jug, the 15% figure tells you how much extra virgin oil is in the mix.
- Turn it around for the origin. A long list of countries means a multi-country blend. Kirkland’s 100% Spanish and Italian extra virgin bottles are single-origin oils.
- Compare price per liter. Mashed lists the 3-liter 100% Spanish extra virgin at $28.49, the 2-liter Italian extra virgin at $31 and the 2-liter organic extra virgin at $21. By my math, that’s about $9.50, $15.50 and $10.50 per liter, compared with $7.50 for the blend. Prices vary by warehouse.
- Match the oil to the job. The Takeout calls the blend fine for higher-heat cooking, like greasing sheet pans, browning ground meat, stir-frying vegetables and baking, but not for finishing or dipping.
Plan B if you want both savings and flavor: keep the big jug for everyday cooking and buy a smaller bottle of extra virgin for salads, bread and drizzling.
What the label doesn’t mean
The blend isn’t a trick. “Olive oil” is a recognized USDA grade, and the jug states its 15% extra virgin content on the front. It’s simply a different product from extra virgin oil, with a different job in the kitchen.
Prices change, too. Mashed notes that the blend costs more in some regions, and earlier reviews listed lower prices, so check the shelf tag at your own warehouse before you compare.
Storage matters whichever bottle you buy. A separate Mashed review pointed out that the clear plastic bottle lets in light, which can reduce antioxidants and promote rancidity. Heat is a problem too, which is why the cabinet over the stove is the worst spot for olive oil.
Read the front for the grade, the back for the origin, and buy for the job. That’s the trick.





